Is Jacob Elordi Too HOT to Play Frankenstein's Monster?!
Guillermo del Toro's new adaptation of Mary Shelley's classic novel, *Frankenstein*, has sparked debate, primarily due to the casting of Jacob Elordi as the iconic monster. Known for his roles in *Euphoria*, *Priscilla*, and *Saltburn*, Elordi's striking good looks have led some to question whether he's the right fit for a creature traditionally portrayed as grotesque and terrifying.
A Hunky Monster?
Critics argue that making Frankenstein's monster conventionally attractive misses the point of Shelley's original story. The monster's ugliness is integral to his alienation and suffering. One review humorously suggests, "Giving him a makeover is like having a vegetarian Dracula!" If the monster isn't visually repulsive, does he truly embody the tragic figure at the heart of the narrative?
However, others contend that Elordi's casting offers a fresh perspective. Del Toro seems to be emphasizing the romantic and tragic elements of the story, portraying the monster as a misunderstood outsider, akin to a James Dean figure. While Elordi sports scars and stitches, he remains undeniably handsome. This interpretation shifts the focus from pure horror to a more nuanced exploration of loneliness, rejection, and the search for identity.
Oscar Isaac's Mad Scientist
Adding another layer to the dynamic is Oscar Isaac's portrayal of Victor Frankenstein. Reviews suggest Isaac delivers a mannered and uneven performance, initially presenting Victor as a sinister and egomaniacal scientist. However, he gains strength later, depicting Victor as a broken and despairing man, consumed by remorse. This contrast between Elordi's sympathetic monster and Isaac's flawed creator could offer a compelling twist on the classic tale.
A Faithful Adaptation?
Despite the casting choices, some argue that Del Toro's *Frankenstein* is a more faithful adaptation of Shelley's novel than many previous versions. However, the film faces the challenge of overcoming audience's ingrained expectations shaped by decades of cinematic interpretations, from the Universal movies to Mel Brooks's spoof. Will Del Toro's visually stunning and romanticized version resonate with audiences familiar with the monster's traditional image? Only time will tell.
- The film premiered at the Venice Film Festival.
- It will be released in theaters on October 17th and streaming on November 7th.
- The cast includes Mia Goth, Christoph Waltz, and Charles Dance.